back to indexAriel Ekblaw: Space Colonization and Self-Assembling Space Megastructures | Lex Fridman Podcast #271
link |
We think that self assembly,
link |
this modular reconfigurable algorithm
link |
for constructing space structures in orbit
link |
is gonna give us this promise of space architecture
link |
that's actually worth living in.
link |
You see, you do believe we might one day
link |
become intergalactic civilization.
link |
I have a hope, yeah.
link |
The following is a conversation with Ariel Ekblah,
link |
Director of MIT Space Exploration Initiative.
link |
She's especially interested in autonomously
link |
self assembling space architectures.
link |
Basically, giant space structures
link |
that can sustain human life
link |
and that assemble themselves out in space
link |
and then orbit Earth, Moon, Mars, and other planets.
link |
This is the Lex Friedman podcast.
link |
To support it, please check out our sponsors
link |
in the description.
link |
And now, dear friends, here's Ariel Ekblah.
link |
When did you first fall in love with space exploration
link |
and space in general?
link |
My parents are both ex Air Force.
link |
So my dad's an A10 fighter pilot
link |
and my mom trained and had qualified to be a fighter pilot,
link |
but it was early enough
link |
that women were not allowed in combat at that time.
link |
And so I grew up with these two pilots
link |
and although they themselves did not become astronauts,
link |
there's a really rich legacy of Air Force pilots
link |
becoming astronauts and this loomed large in my childhood.
link |
What does it mean to be courageous, to be an explorer,
link |
to be at the vanguard of something hard and challenging?
link |
And to couple with that,
link |
my dad was a huge fan of science fiction.
link |
And so I, as a kid, read Heinlein and Isaac Asimov,
link |
all these different classics of science fiction
link |
that he had introduced me to.
link |
And that just started a love affair with space exploration
link |
and really thinking about
link |
civilization scale space exploration.
link |
So did they themselves dream about going to the stars
link |
as opposed to flying here in Earth's atmosphere,
link |
Yeah, my dad always said he was absolutely convinced
link |
because he was a child of the Apollo years
link |
that he would get to go in his lifetime,
link |
really thought it was gonna happen.
link |
And so it was a challenge and sad for many people
link |
when to their view on the outside,
link |
space exploration slowed down for a period of time.
link |
In reality, we were just catching up.
link |
I think we leapt so far ahead with Apollo,
link |
more than the rest of society was ready for.
link |
And now we're coming back to this moment
link |
for space exploration where we actually have an economy
link |
and we have the other accoutrement that society needs
link |
to be able to make space exploration more real.
link |
And my dad's thrilled because finally,
link |
not nearly, I hope not anywhere near the end of his life,
link |
but as he's an older man,
link |
he now can see still within his lifetime,
link |
people really getting a chance
link |
to build a sustainable lunar settlement on the moon
link |
or maybe even go to Mars.
link |
So settlement, civilizations and other planets,
link |
that's the cool thing to dream about in the future.
link |
What was the favorite sci fi authors when you were growing up?
link |
Pabé Eszeg Asimov Foundation Trilogy.
link |
This is an amazing story of Harry Seldon,
link |
this foundation that he forms at different ends of the,
link |
well, according to the story,
link |
different ends of the universe
link |
and has this interesting focus on society.
link |
So it's not just space exploration
link |
for the sake of space exploration or novel technology,
link |
which is a lot of what I work on day to day at MIT,
link |
but how do you structure a society
link |
across those vast expanses of distance and time?
link |
And so I'd say absolutely a favorite.
link |
Now though, my favorite is Neal Stephenson and Seveneves.
link |
It's a book that inspired my own PhD research
link |
and some ongoing work that we're doing with NASA now
link |
for the future of swarm robotics for spacecraft.
link |
We were saying offline about Neal Stephenson
link |
because I just recently had a conversation with him.
link |
And I said that not until I was doing the research for him
link |
that I realized he also had a role to play in Blue Origin.
link |
So it's like sci fi actually having a role to play
link |
in the design, engineering,
link |
just the implementation of ideas
link |
that kind of percolate up from the sci fi world
link |
and actually become reality.
link |
It's kind of a fascinating figure in that way.
link |
So do you also think about him
link |
beyond just his work in science fiction,
link |
but his role in coming up with wild, crazy ideas
link |
that actually become reality?
link |
Yes, I think it's a great example of this cycle
link |
between authors and scientists and engineers
link |
that we can be inspired in one generation
link |
by what authors dream up.
link |
We build it, we make it a reality.
link |
And then that inspires another generation
link |
of really wild and crazy thought for science fiction.
link |
I think Neal Stephenson does a beautiful job
link |
of being what we'd call a hard science fiction author.
link |
So it's really grounded in a lot of science,
link |
which makes it very compelling for me
link |
as a scientist and engineer to read
link |
and then be challenged to make that vision a reality.
link |
The other community that Neal's involved with
link |
and some of my other mentors are involved with
link |
that we are thinking about more and more in the work
link |
that we do at MIT is the Long Now Foundation.
link |
And this focus on what does society need to take
link |
in terms of steps at this juncture,
link |
this particular inflection point in human history
link |
to make sure that we're setting ourselves up
link |
for a long and prosperous horizon,
link |
for humanity's horizons.
link |
There's a lot of examples
link |
of what the Long Now Foundation does and thinks about.
link |
But when I think about this in my own work,
link |
it's what does it take to scale humanity's presence
link |
We are seeing some additional investment
link |
in commercial space habitats.
link |
So it'll no longer be just NASA
link |
running the International Space Station,
link |
but to really democratize access to space,
link |
like Bezos wants to have millions of people living
link |
and working in space,
link |
you need architecture that's bigger and grander
link |
and can actually scale.
link |
That means you need to be thinking about
link |
how can you construct things for long time horizons
link |
that are really sustainable in orbit
link |
or on a surface of a celestial body
link |
that are bigger than the biggest rocket payload fairing
link |
that we currently have available.
link |
And that what led me to self assembly
link |
and other models of in space construction.
link |
Okay, every time you speak,
link |
I get like a million tangent ideas.
link |
You can cut me off.
link |
No, no, no, no, no, no, please keep talking.
link |
I just, there's like a million of ideas.
link |
So one sort of on the dark side, let me ask,
link |
do you think about the threats to human civilization
link |
that kind of motivate the scaling of the expansion
link |
of humans in space and on other planets?
link |
What are you worried about?
link |
Nuclear war, pandemics,
link |
super intelligent, artificial intelligence systems,
link |
more not existential crises,
link |
but ones that have significant,
link |
potentially significant detrimental effects on society,
link |
like climate change, those kinds of things.
link |
And then there's of course the fun S story
link |
coming out from the darkness and hitting all earth.
link |
There's been a few movies on that.
link |
Anyway, is there something that you think about
link |
that threatens us in this century?
link |
I mean, as an ex military family,
link |
we used to talk about all of this.
link |
We would say that luck favors the prepared.
link |
And so growing up, we had a plan, actually a family plan
link |
for what we would do in a pandemic.
link |
Didn't think we were gonna have to put that
link |
and plan into place and here we are.
link |
We do, certainly among my own family and my friends
link |
and then our work at MIT,
link |
we do think about existential threats and risks to humanity
link |
and what role does space exploration
link |
and getting humans off world have to play
link |
in a resilient future for humanity.
link |
But what I actually find more compelling recently
link |
is instead of thinking about a need to ever abandon earth
link |
through a path of space exploration or space foraging
link |
is to see how we can use space technology
link |
to keep earth livable.
link |
The obvious direct ways of doing this would be,
link |
satellite technology that's helping us learn more
link |
about climate change or emitters or CO2.
link |
But there's also a future for geo engineering
link |
that might be space based.
link |
A lot of questions that would have to be answered
link |
around that, but these are examples of pivoting our focus
link |
away from maybe the Hollywood vision of,
link |
oh, an asteroid's gonna come,
link |
we're all gonna have to escape earth
link |
to let's use our considerable technology prowess
link |
and use space technology to save earth
link |
and be very much focused on how we can have
link |
a worthwhile life for earth citizens.
link |
Even if some of us wanna go out and further venturing.
link |
Right, just the desire to explore the mysterious, yes.
link |
But also it does seem that by placing us
link |
in harsh conditions, the harsh conditions of space,
link |
the harsh conditions of planets,
link |
and the biology, the chemistry, the engineering,
link |
the robotics, the materials, all of that,
link |
that's just a nice way to come up with cool new things.
link |
Great forcing function, yeah.
link |
Yeah, exactly, it's a forcing function like survival.
link |
You don't get this right, you die.
link |
So, and that you can bring back to earth
link |
and it will improve, like figuring out food in space
link |
will make you figure out how to eat,
link |
live healthier lives here on earth.
link |
So true, I mean, some of the technologies
link |
that we're directly looking at right now
link |
for space habitats, it's hard to keep humans alive
link |
in this really fragile little pocket against the vacuum
link |
and all of the dangers that the space environment presents.
link |
Some of the technologies we are gonna have to figure out
link |
is energy efficient cooling and air conditioning,
link |
air filtration, scrubbing CO2 from the air,
link |
being able to have habitats that are themselves resilient
link |
to extremes of space weather and radiation.
link |
And some of these are direct translational opportunities
link |
for areas turned by natural disasters.
link |
People in California a decade ago would never have had
link |
to think about having an airtight house.
link |
But now with wildfires, maybe you do want something close
link |
to an airtight house, how do you manage that?
link |
There's a lot of technologies
link |
from the space habitation world
link |
that we are hoping we can actually bring back down
link |
to benefit life on earth as well
link |
in these extreme environment contexts.
link |
Okay, so you mentioned to go back to swarm.
link |
So that was interesting to you,
link |
first of all, in your own work,
link |
but also I believe you said something
link |
that was inspiring from Niel Stevenson as well.
link |
So when you say swarm, are you thinking about
link |
architectures or are you thinking about
link |
artificial intelligence like robotics
link |
or are those kind of intermixed?
link |
I think the future that we're seeing
link |
is that they're going to be intermixed,
link |
which is really exciting.
link |
So the future of space habitats
link |
are one of intelligent structures,
link |
maybe not all the way to Hal
link |
and the 2001 Space Odyssey reference that scares people
link |
about the habitat having a mind of its own.
link |
But certainly we're building systems now
link |
where the habitat has sensing technology
link |
that allows it to communicate its basic functions,
link |
maintaining life support for the astronauts,
link |
but could also communicate in symbiosis
link |
with these swarm robots
link |
that would be on the outside of the spacecraft,
link |
whether it's in a microgravity orbiting environment
link |
or on the surface.
link |
And these little robots,
link |
they crawl just a la Niel Stevenson in seven eves,
link |
they crawl along the outside of the spacecraft
link |
looking for micrometeorite punctures
link |
or gas leaks or other faults and defects.
link |
And right now we're just working on the diagnosis.
link |
So can the swarm with its collective intelligence
link |
act in symbiosis with the spacecraft and detect things?
link |
But in the future we'd also love
link |
for these little micro robots to repair in situ
link |
and really be like ants living in a tree
link |
altogether connected to the spacecraft.
link |
Do you envision the system to be fully distributed
link |
and just like an ant colony,
link |
if one of them is damaged or whatever,
link |
loses control and all those kinds of things
link |
that doesn't affect the performance of the complete system
link |
or doesn't need to be centralized?
link |
This is more like almost like a technical question.
link |
Do you think we can?
link |
Good architecture question.
link |
Right, from the ground up,
link |
it's so scary to go fully distributed.
link |
But it's also exceptionally powerful, right?
link |
Robust, resilient to the harsh conditions of space.
link |
What do you, if you look into the next 10, 20, 100 years,
link |
starting from scratch,
link |
do you think we should be doing
link |
architecture wise distributed systems?
link |
For space, yes, because it gives you this redundancy
link |
and safety profile that's really critical.
link |
So whether it's small swarm robots
link |
where it doesn't matter if you lose a few of them,
link |
to habitats that instead of having a central monolithic habitat,
link |
you might actually be able to have
link |
a decentralized node of a space station
link |
so that you can kind of right out of Star Wars,
link |
you can shut a blast door if there's a fire
link |
or if there's a conflict in a certain area
link |
and you can move the humans and the crew
link |
into another decentralized node of the spacecraft.
link |
There's another idea out of Neal Stephenson's Seven Eves
link |
actually where these arclets,
link |
which were decentralized spacecraft that could form
link |
and dock little temporary space stations with each other
link |
and then separate and go off on their way
link |
and have a decentralized approach to living in space.
link |
So the self assembly component of that too,
link |
so this is your PhD work and beyond,
link |
you explored autonomously self assembling space architecture
link |
for future space, tourists, habitats,
link |
and space stations in orbit around Earth, Moon, and Mars.
link |
There's few things I personally find sexier
link |
than autonomously self assembling space architecture.
link |
In general, it doesn't even need to be space.
link |
The idea of self assembling architectures
link |
is really interesting, like building a bridge
link |
or something like that through self assembling materials.
link |
It feels like an incredibly efficient way to do it
link |
because optimization is built in.
link |
So you can build the most optimal structures
link |
given dynamic, uncertain, changing conditions.
link |
So maybe can you talk about your PhD work,
link |
about this work, about Tesserae, what is it in general?
link |
Any cool stuff, because this is super cool.
link |
Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
link |
So Tesserae is my PhD research.
link |
It's this idea that we could take tiles
link |
that construct a large structure like a bucky ball.
link |
Yeah, this is exactly what we're looking at here,
link |
which is the tiles that are packed flat in a rocket.
link |
They're released to float in microgravity.
link |
Magnets, pretty powerful, electropermanent magnets
link |
on their edges draw them together for autonomous docking.
link |
So there's no human in the loop here,
link |
and there's no central agent coordinating
link |
saying tile one, go to tile two.
link |
It's completely decentralized system.
link |
They find each other on their own.
link |
What we don't show in this video
link |
is what happens if there's an error, right?
link |
So what happens if they bond incorrectly?
link |
The tiles have sensing, so proximity sensing,
link |
magnetometer, other sensors that allow them
link |
to detect a good bond versus a bad bond
link |
and pulse off and self correct,
link |
which anybody who works in the field of self assembly
link |
will tell you that error detection and correction,
link |
just like error detection in a DNA sequence
link |
or protein folding is really important part of the system
link |
for that robustness.
link |
And so we've done a lot of work to engineer that ability
link |
for the tiles to be self determining.
link |
They know whether they're forming the structure
link |
that they're supposed to form or not.
link |
They know if they're in a toxic relationship
link |
and they need to get out.
link |
Right, right, if they need to separate, exactly, yeah.
link |
All right, this is like so amazing.
link |
And for people who are just listening to this,
link |
yeah, there's, I mean, how large are these tiles?
link |
So the size that we use in the lab,
link |
they can really be any size
link |
because we can scale them down to do testing
link |
So we sent tiles that were about three inches wide
link |
to the International Space Station a couple years ago
link |
to test the code, test the state machine,
link |
test the algorithm of self assembly.
link |
But now we're actually building
link |
our first ever human scale tiles.
link |
They're me human size.
link |
So a little smaller than maybe your average human,
link |
but they're 2.5 feet on edge length.
link |
The larger scale that we would love to build in the future
link |
would actually be tiles that are big enough
link |
to form a bucky ball, big open spherical volume,
link |
spherical approximation volume,
link |
that'd be about 10 meters in diameter.
link |
So 30 feet, which is much bigger and grander
link |
in terms of open space than any current module on the ISS.
link |
And one of the goals of this project was to say,
link |
what's the purpose of next generation space architecture?
link |
Should it be something that really inspires
link |
and delights people when you float into that space?
link |
Can you get goosebumps in the way that you do
link |
when you walk into a really stunning piece
link |
of architecture on earth?
link |
And so we think that self assembly,
link |
this modular reconfigurable algorithm
link |
for constructing space structures in orbit
link |
is gonna give us this promise of space architecture
link |
that's actually worth living in.
link |
Living in, oh, I thought you also meant
link |
from like outside artistic perspective,
link |
when you see the whole thing is just.
link |
With the aesthetics of it, absolutely.
link |
You know, when you like go like into Vegas,
link |
whenever you go into a city
link |
and it like over the hill appears in front of you.
link |
And I mean, there's something majestic about seeing like,
link |
wow, humans created that.
link |
It gives you like hope about like,
link |
if these a bunch of ants were able to figure out
link |
how to build skyscrapers that light up.
link |
And in general, the design of these tiles
link |
in the way you envision it are pretty scalable.
link |
Yes, and they're inspired by exactly
link |
what you mentioned a moment ago,
link |
which is we have these patterns of self assembly on earth.
link |
And there's a lot of fantastic MIT research
link |
that we're building this concept on.
link |
So like Daniela Ruse at CSAIL and Pebbles,
link |
taking the power of magnets to create units
link |
that are themselves interchangeable,
link |
this notion of programmable matter.
link |
And so we're interested in going really big with it
link |
to build big scale space structures with programmable tiles.
link |
But there's also a really fascinating,
link |
you know, end of that on the other side of the spectrum,
link |
which is how small can you go with matter
link |
that's programmable and stacks and builds itself
link |
and creates a bridge or something in the future.
link |
What do you envision the thing would look like?
link |
Like when you imagine a thing far into the future
link |
where there's, so we're not even thinking about
link |
like small space, well, let's not call them small,
link |
but our currently sized space stations,
link |
but like something gigantic, what do you envision?
link |
Is this something with symmetry
link |
or is this something we can't even come up with yet?
link |
Is there beautiful structures that you imagine in your mind?
link |
I've got three candidates that I would love to build.
link |
If we're talking about monumental space architecture,
link |
one is what does a space cathedral look like?
link |
It can be a secular cathedral,
link |
doesn't necessarily have to be about religion,
link |
but that notion of long sight lines,
link |
inspiring, stunning architecture when you go in.
link |
And you can imagine floating instead of, you know,
link |
being on the ground and only looking up in space,
link |
you could be in a central node
link |
and each direction you look at,
link |
all the cardinal directions are spires going off
link |
in a really large and long way.
link |
So that's concept number one.
link |
Number two would be something more organic
link |
that's not just geometric.
link |
So here, one of the ideas that we're working on at MIT
link |
in my lab is to say, could you,
link |
instead of the tesserae model, right,
link |
which is self assembling a shell,
link |
could you define a module that's a node,
link |
a small node that someone can live in
link |
and you self assemble a lot of those together,
link |
they're called plesiohedrons like space filling solids
link |
and you dock a bunch of them together
link |
and you can create a really organic structure out of that.
link |
So this is the same way that muscles accrete to appear,
link |
you can have these nodes that dock together
link |
and one shape that I would love to form out of this
link |
is something like a nautilus, a seashell,
link |
that beautiful, you know, fibonacci spiral sequence
link |
that you get in that shape,
link |
which I think would be a stunning
link |
and fabulous aggregated space station.
link |
You said so many cool words, plesiohedron.
link |
Yeah, plesiohedron.
link |
So that's a space filling.
link |
Solid, the simplest thing to think of is like a cube.
link |
Oh, cube. A cube, right?
link |
So you can stack cubes together
link |
and if you had an infinite number of cubes,
link |
you'd fill all that space,
link |
there's no gaps in between the cubes,
link |
they stack and fill space.
link |
Another plesiohedron is a truncated octahedron
link |
and that's actually one of the candidate structures
link |
that we think would be great for space stations.
link |
What's the truncated part?
link |
Ah, so you cut off,
link |
an octahedron actually has little pointy areas,
link |
you truncate certain sections of it
link |
and you get surfaces that are on the structure
link |
that are cubes and I think hexagons,
link |
I have to remind myself exactly what the faces are.
link |
But overall, a truncated octahedron can be bonded
link |
to other truncated octahedrons
link |
and just like a cube, it fills all the gaps
link |
as you build it out.
link |
So you can imagine two truncated octahedrons,
link |
they come together at an airlock,
link |
which is what we space people call doors in space
link |
and you dock them on all sides
link |
and you've basically created this decentralized network
link |
of space nodes that make a big space station
link |
and once you have enough of them
link |
and you're growing with enough big units,
link |
you can do it in any macro shape you want.
link |
That's where the Nautilus comes in,
link |
is could we design an organically inspired shape
link |
for a space station?
link |
Can I just say how awesome it is to hear you say,
link |
I know you meant people that are doing research
link |
on space exploration, space technology,
link |
but it also made me think of a future.
link |
There's earth people and there's those space people.
link |
And then there's the Mars people.
link |
I'd love to unite those too.
link |
Yeah, no, no, for sure, for sure.
link |
But like, it's like New Yorkers and like Texans
link |
or something like that.
link |
Yeah, of course you live for a time in New York
link |
and then you go up to Boston
link |
but for a time you're the space people.
link |
Oh, I know those space people.
link |
They're kind of wild up there.
link |
We'll see how that dynamic evolves.
link |
There's that culture, culture forms.
link |
And I would love to see what kind of culture,
link |
once you have sort of more and more civilians.
link |
I mean, there's a human,
link |
I mean, I love psychology and sociology
link |
and I'll maybe ask you about that too,
link |
which is like the dynamic between humans.
link |
You have to kind of start considering that
link |
and you start spending more and more time up in space
link |
and start sending civilians, start sending bigger
link |
and bigger groups of people.
link |
And then of course the beautiful and the ugly emerges
link |
from the human nature that we haven't been able
link |
to escape up to this point.
link |
But when you say the plesiohedrons, these kinds of shapes,
link |
are they multifunctional?
link |
Like is the idea you'd be able to,
link |
humans can occupy them safely in some of them
link |
and some others have some other purposes?
link |
One could be sleeping quarters.
link |
One could be a greenhouse or an agricultural unit.
link |
One could be a storage depot.
link |
Essentially all of the different rooms
link |
or functions that you might need in a space station
link |
could be subdivided into these nodes
link |
and then stacked together.
link |
And one of the promises of both Tesseray,
link |
my original PhD research, which is these shells,
link |
and then this follow on node concept,
link |
is that right now we build space stations
link |
and once they're built, they're done.
link |
You can't really change them profoundly.
link |
But the benefit of a modular self assembling system
link |
is you can disassemble it.
link |
You can completely reconfigure it.
link |
So if your mission changes or the number of people
link |
in space that you wanna host,
link |
if you have a space conference happening
link |
like South by Southwest.
link |
I was thinking space party,
link |
but space conference is good too.
link |
Then maybe all of a sudden you want to change out
link |
what were window tiles yesterday, cupola tiles,
link |
and make them into a birthing port
link |
so that you can welcome five new spaceships
link |
to come and join you in space.
link |
That's what this promise of reconfigurable space architecture
link |
might allow us to explore.
link |
I've been hanging out with Grimes recently
link |
and I just feel like she belongs up in space.
link |
This is like designed for artists essentially.
link |
Like imagine, I mean, this is what South by
link |
keeps introducing me to is there's like
link |
the weird and the beautiful people and like the artists.
link |
And it feels like there's a lot of opportunities
link |
for art and design.
link |
It's like space is a combination of arts, design,
link |
and great engineering.
link |
It's safety critical with like the highest of stakes.
link |
So don't, you can't mess it up.
link |
And is this, is there, first of all,
link |
you're talking about tiling.
link |
So Neil Stephenson is obsessed about tile.
link |
I don't know if it's related to any of this,
link |
but he seems to be obsessed with like,
link |
how do you tile a space?
link |
That's like a mathematical, geometric notion.
link |
Like the tessellation.
link |
And it's, I mean, it's a beautiful idea for architecture
link |
that you can self assemble these different shapes
link |
and you can have probably some centralized guidance
link |
of the kind of thing you want to build.
link |
But they also kind of figure stuff out themselves
link |
in terms of the low level details,
link |
in terms of the figuring out when the,
link |
when everything fits just right for the OCD people,
link |
like what's that subreddit?
link |
Pleasantly, it's like really fun.
link |
Everything, they have like videos of everything
link |
is just pleasant when everything just fits perfectly.
link |
All the tolerances come together well, yeah.
link |
So they figure that out on themselves
link |
and the local robotics problem.
link |
But by the way, what's the Pebbles Project?
link |
The Pebbles Project are little cubes
link |
that have EPMs in them, electropermanent magnets,
link |
and they can self disassemble.
link |
So they'll turn off.
link |
And so you'll have this little structure
link |
that all of a sudden can flip the little pebbles over
link |
and essentially just disaggregate.
link |
They have to make some pleasing sounds.
link |
And that's gonna, so I'm supposed to talk to Danielle,
link |
so I'll probably spend an hour
link |
just discussing the sounds on the pebbles.
link |
Okay, what were we talking about?
link |
So that's, because you mentioned two, I think.
link |
Right, my third one.
link |
Yeah, is there a third one?
link |
My third one is The Ringworld,
link |
just because every science fiction book ever
link |
that's worth anything has A Ringworld in it.
link |
Is it like a donut?
link |
A donut, yeah, it's a really big torus
link |
that could encircle a planet
link |
or encircle another celestial body,
link |
maybe an asteroid or a small moon.
link |
And the promise here is just the beauty
link |
of being able to have that geometry in orbit
link |
and all that surface area for solar panels and docking
link |
and essentially just all of what that enables
link |
to have a ring world at that scale in orbit.
link |
By the way, for the viewers, we're looking at Figure 11.
link |
What paper is this from?
link |
This is a hexagonal tiling
link |
of a torus generated in Mathematica
link |
referencing code and approach from two citations.
link |
So we're looking at a tiled donut, and I'm now hungry.
link |
So this is the, is this from your thesis or no?
link |
This is probably, I mean, this is in my thesis.
link |
This looks like it was one of my earlier papers.
link |
This was an approach to say, great,
link |
we've come up with this tessellation approach
link |
for a buckyball, and we picked the buckyball
link |
because it is the most efficient surface area
link |
to volume shape and what's expensive in space,
link |
the surface area shipping up all that material.
link |
So we wanted something that would maximize the volume.
link |
But if we think about ring worlds and other shapes,
link |
we wanted to look at how do you tile a torus?
link |
And this is one example with hexagons
link |
to be able to say, could we take this same tesserae approach
link |
of self assembling tiles and create other geometries?
link |
This is so freaking cool.
link |
So you mentioned microgravity, and I saw,
link |
I believe that there's a picture
link |
of you floating in microgravity.
link |
When did you get to experience that?
link |
What was that like?
link |
Ah, so I've flown nine times
link |
on the affectionately known as the Vomit Comet.
link |
It's the parabolic flight, and essentially,
link |
it does what you'd want a plane never to do.
link |
It pitches really steeply upwards at 45 degrees.
link |
Oh, that's a picture of you.
link |
Yeah, yeah, that's tesserae.
link |
That's super early in my PhD,
link |
some of just the passive tiles
link |
before we even put electronics in.
link |
We were just testing the magnet polarity
link |
and the, essentially, is it an energy favorable structure
link |
to self assemble on its own?
link |
So we tweaked a lot of things between.
link |
Are we looking at a couple of them?
link |
Yeah, you're looking at a bunch of them there.
link |
Almost 32 of them, yeah.
link |
They're clumping, they're clumping, yeah.
link |
Can you comment on what's the difference
link |
between microgravity and zero gravity?
link |
Yes, so there is, is that an important difference?
link |
It's an important difference.
link |
There is no zero gravity.
link |
There's no nothing, there's, in the universe,
link |
there is no such thing as zero gravity.
link |
So Newton's law of gravity tells us
link |
that there's always gravity attraction
link |
between any two objects.
link |
So zero G is a shorthand that some of us fall into using,
link |
where it's a little easier to communicate to the public.
link |
The accurate term is microgravity,
link |
where you are essentially floating, you're weightless,
link |
but generally in free fall.
link |
So on the parabolic flights, the vomit comet,
link |
you're in free fall at the end of the parabola.
link |
And in orbit around the Earth when you're floating,
link |
you're also in free fall.
link |
So that's microgravity.
link |
So affectionately called vomit comet,
link |
I'm sure there's a reason why it's called affectionately.
link |
So what's it like?
link |
What's your first time?
link |
So both philosophically, spiritually, and biologically,
link |
It is unlike anything else you will experience on Earth
link |
because it is this true feeling of weightlessness
link |
So the closest experience you can think of
link |
would be floating in a pool,
link |
but you move slowly when you float in a pool
link |
and your motion is restricted.
link |
When you're floating, it's just you and your body flying,
link |
It takes the littlest amount of energy,
link |
like a finger tap against the wall of the plane
link |
to shoot all the way across the fuselage.
link |
And you can move at full speed.
link |
You can move your arms.
link |
So your muscles work.
link |
There's no resistance.
link |
There's no resistance.
link |
They actually tell you to make a memory
link |
when you're on the plane
link |
because it's such a fleeting experience for your body
link |
that even a few days later,
link |
you've already forgotten exactly what it felt like.
link |
It's so foreign to the human experience.
link |
They kind of suggest that you explicitly try
link |
to really form this into a memory
link |
and then you can do the replay.
link |
Is that for training?
link |
Cognitively freeze it.
link |
When we have Neuralink, we can replay that memory.
link |
So in terms of how much stress it has on your body,
link |
is it biologically stressful?
link |
You do feel a 2G pullout, right?
link |
So the cost of getting those micro G parabolas
link |
is you then have a 2G pullout and that's hard.
link |
You have to train for it.
link |
If you move your neck too quickly in that 2G pullout,
link |
you can strain muscles.
link |
But I wouldn't say that it's actually
link |
a profound tough thing on the body.
link |
It's really just an incredibly novel experience.
link |
And when you're in orbit
link |
and you're not having to go through the ups and downs
link |
of the parabolic plane,
link |
there's a real grace and elegance.
link |
And you see the astronauts learn to operate
link |
in this completely new environment.
link |
What are some interesting differences
link |
between the parabolic plane
link |
and when you're actually going up into orbit?
link |
Is it that with orbit you can look out
link |
and see that blue little planet of ours?
link |
You can see the blue marble, the stunning overview effect,
link |
which is something I hope to see one day.
link |
What's also really different is if you're in orbit
link |
for any significant period of time,
link |
there's gonna be a lot more physiological changes
link |
to your body than if you just did an afternoon flight
link |
on the Vomit Comet.
link |
Everything from your bones, your muscles,
link |
your eyeballs change shape.
link |
There's a lot of different things that happen
link |
for long duration space flight.
link |
And we still have to, as scientists,
link |
we still have to solve a lot of these interesting challenges
link |
to be able to keep humans thriving in microgravity
link |
or deep duration space missions.
link |
Deep duration space missions.
link |
Okay, let's talk about this.
link |
I was just gonna ask a bunch of dumb questions.
link |
So approximately how long does it take to travel to Mars?
link |
Asking for a friend.
link |
Asking for a friend, as we all do.
link |
About three years for a round trip.
link |
And that's not that it actually takes that long.
link |
Why the round trip, is that?
link |
Well, you're just asking about the one way trip.
link |
Got it, got it, got it.
link |
So for just like literally flying to Mars in a round,
link |
it takes three years.
link |
There's some interstitial time there
link |
because you really can only go between Earth and Mars
link |
at certain points in their orbits
link |
where it's favorable to make that journey.
link |
And so part of that three years
link |
is you take the journey to Mars,
link |
a few months, six to nine months.
link |
You're there for a period of time
link |
until the orbits find a favorable alignment again.
link |
And then you come back another six to nine months.
link |
So one way travel, six to nine months.
link |
They hang out there on vacation and come back.
link |
Well, me who loves working all the time,
link |
all vacation is forced vacation.
link |
So okay, so that gives us a sense of duration.
link |
And we can maybe also talk about longer
link |
and longer and longer duration as well.
link |
What are the hardest aspects of living in space
link |
for many days, for let's say 100 days, 200 days?
link |
Maybe there's a threshold when it gets really tough.
link |
What are some stupid little things or big things
link |
that are very difficult for human beings to go through?
link |
It's one big thing and one little thing.
link |
And there are these two classic problems
link |
that we're trying to solve in the space industry.
link |
It's not as much of a problem for us right now
link |
on the International Space Station
link |
because we're still protected
link |
by part of Earth's magnetosphere.
link |
But as soon as you get farther out into space
link |
and you don't have that protection
link |
once you leave the Van Allen belt area of the Earth
link |
and the cocoon around the Earth,
link |
we have really serious concerns about radiation
link |
and the effect on human health longterm.
link |
That's the big one.
link |
The small one, and I say it's small
link |
because it seems mundane,
link |
but it actually is really big in its own way,
link |
is mental health and how to keep people happy and balanced.
link |
And you were alluding to some of the psychological
link |
challenges of having humans together on missions
link |
and especially as we try to scale the number of humans
link |
in orbit or in space.
link |
So that's another big challenge is how to keep people happy
link |
and balanced and cooperating.
link |
That's not an issue on Earth at all.
link |
Okay, so we'll talk about each of those
link |
in a bit more detail,
link |
but let me continue on the chain of dumb questions.
link |
What's a good source for food in space?
link |
And what are some sort of standard go to meals, menus?
link |
Right now your go to menu is gonna be mostly freeze dried.
link |
Every so often NASA will arrange for a fun stunt
link |
or fresh food to get up to station.
link |
So they did bake DoubleTree cookies with Hilton
link |
a couple of years ago, as I recall,
link |
I think sometime before the pandemic.
link |
But there's work actually in our lab at MIT,
link |
Maggie Koblans, one of my staff researchers
link |
is looking at the future of fermentation.
link |
Everybody loves beer, right?
link |
Beer and wine and kimchi and miso,
link |
these foods that have just been really important
link |
to human cultures for eons because we love the umami
link |
and the better flavor in them.
link |
But it turns out they also have a good shelf life
link |
And they also have a additional health benefit
link |
for the microbiome, for probiotics and prebiotics.
link |
So we're trying to work with NASA and convince them
link |
to be more open minded to fermented food
link |
for long duration deep space missions.
link |
That we think is one of the future elements
link |
in addition to in situ growing your own food.
link |
Okay, this is essential for the space party
link |
is the space beer.
link |
Yes, it's the fermented product, yes.
link |
In terms of water, what's a good source of drinkable water?
link |
Like where do you get water?
link |
Do you have to always bring it on board with you?
link |
And is there a compressed efficient way of storing it?
link |
So to steal a line from Charlie Bolden,
link |
who's the former administrator of NASA,
link |
this morning's fresh water is yesterday's coffee.
link |
So if you think about what that means,
link |
you drank the coffee yesterday.
link |
Right, as it travels, it goes fully through the body.
link |
Fully through the body as the recycling system.
link |
And then you drink what you peed out
link |
as clarified, refined fresh water the next day.
link |
That is one source of water.
link |
Another source of water in the near neighborhood
link |
of our solar system would be on the moon.
link |
So water ice deposits, there's also water on Mars.
link |
This is one of the big things that's bringing people
link |
to want to develop infrastructure on the moon
link |
is once you've gotten out of the gravity well of Earth,
link |
if you can find water on the moon and refine it,
link |
you can either make it into propellant
link |
or drinkable water for humans.
link |
And so that's really valuable as a potential gateway
link |
out into the rest of the solar system
link |
to be able to get propellant
link |
without always having to ship it up from Earth.
link |
So how much water is there on Mars?
link |
That's a great question.
link |
We don't know this yet, right?
link |
I know there's water at the caps.
link |
I suspect NASA from all of the satellite studies
link |
that they've done at Mars have a decent idea
link |
of what the water deposits look like,
link |
but I don't know to what degree
link |
they have characterized those.
link |
I really hope there's life or traces
link |
of previous life on Mars.
link |
This is a special spot in my heart
link |
because I got to work on SHERLOC,
link |
which is the astrobiology experiment
link |
that's on Mars right now,
link |
searching for what they would say
link |
in a very cautious way is signs of past habitability.
link |
They wanna be careful not to get people overly excited
link |
and say we're searching for signs of life.
link |
They're searching to see if there would have been organics
link |
on the surface of Mars or water in certain areas
link |
that would have allowed for life to flourish.
link |
And I really love this prospect.
link |
I do think within our lifetimes
link |
we'll get a better answer about finding life
link |
in our solar system if it's there.
link |
If not on Mars, maybe Europa, one of the icy worlds.
link |
So you like astrobiology.
link |
This is part of the, it's not just about human biology.
link |
It's also other extraterrestrial alien biology.
link |
Search for life in the universe.
link |
Does that scare you or excite you?
link |
It excites me, profoundly excites me.
link |
That there's other alien civilizations
link |
potentially very different than our own?
link |
I think there's gotta be some humility there.
link |
And certainly from science fiction
link |
we have plenty of reasons to fear that outcome as well.
link |
But I do think as a scientist
link |
it would be profoundly exciting if we were to find life
link |
especially in the near neighborhood of our solar system.
link |
Right now we would expect it to be most likely microbial life
link |
but we have a real serious challenge in astrobiology
link |
which is it may not even be carbon based life.
link |
And all of our detectors,
link |
we only know to look for DNA or RNA.
link |
How would you even build a detector
link |
to look for silicon based life
link |
or different molecules than what we know
link |
to be the fundamental molecules for life?
link |
And then you mentioned offline Sarah Walker.
link |
I mean she, her, the question that she's obsessed with
link |
is even just defining life.
link |
To look outside the carbon base.
link |
I mean to look outside of basically anything
link |
we can even imagine chemically.
link |
To look outside of any kind of notions
link |
that we think of as biology.
link |
Yeah, it's really weird.
link |
So you now get into this land of like complexity
link |
of a measuring of like how many assembly steps
link |
it takes to build that thing.
link |
And maybe dynamic movement or some maintenance
link |
of some kind of membrane structures.
link |
We don't even know like which properties life should have.
link |
Whether it should be able to reproduce
link |
and all those kinds of things or pass information,
link |
genetic type of information.
link |
And it's like, it's so humbling.
link |
I mean I tend to believe that there could be
link |
something like alien life here on Earth
link |
and we're just too human, biology obsessed
link |
to even recognize it.
link |
The shadow biosphere, I remember you and Sarah
link |
were talking about.
link |
I mean that's like, speaking of beer,
link |
I mean that's something I wanted to make sure
link |
in all of science to shake ourselves out of like,
link |
remind ourselves constantly how little we know.
link |
Because it might be right in front of our nose.
link |
Like I wouldn't be surprised if like trees
link |
are like orders of magnitude more intelligent than humans.
link |
They're just operating at a much slower scale
link |
and they're like talking shit about us the whole time.
link |
Like about silly humans that take everything seriously
link |
and we start all kinds of nuclear wars
link |
and we quarrel and we tweet about it and then,
link |
but the trees are always there just watching us silly humans.
link |
Like the Ents in Lord of the Rings.
link |
So I mean, I don't know, I mean, obviously I'm joking
link |
on that one, but there could be stuff like that.
link |
Well, let me ask you the Drake equation,
link |
the big question, how many, like obviously nobody knows,
link |
but what's your gut, what's your hope as a scientist,
link |
as a human, how many alien civilizations are out there?
link |
As a ex physicist, I'm now much more
link |
on the aerospace engineering side for space architecture,
link |
but as an ex physicist, I hope it is prolific.
link |
I think the challenge is if it's as prolific
link |
as we would hope, if there are many, many, many
link |
civilizations, then the question is, where are they?
link |
Why haven't we heard from them?
link |
And the Fermi paradox, is there some great filter
link |
that life only gets to some level of sophistication
link |
and then kills itself off through war or through famine
link |
or through different challenges that filter
link |
that society out of existence?
link |
And it would be an interesting question to try
link |
to understand if the universe was teeming with life,
link |
why haven't we found it or heard from it yet,
link |
Yeah, I personally believe that it's teeming with life,
link |
and you're right, I think that's a really useful,
link |
productive engineering scientific question
link |
of what kind of great filter can just be destroying
link |
all of that life or preventing it from just constantly
link |
talking to us, silly descendants of apes.
link |
That's a really nice question, like what are the ways
link |
civilizations can destroy themselves?
link |
There's too many, sadly.
link |
Well, I don't think we've come up with most of them yet.
link |
That's also probably true.
link |
That's the thing, it's, I mean, and if you look
link |
at nuclear war, some of it is physics,
link |
but some of it is game theory, it's human nature,
link |
it's how societies built themselves, how they interact,
link |
how we create and resolve conflict,
link |
and it gets back to the human question
link |
on when you're doing long term space travel,
link |
how do you maintain this dynamical system
link |
of flawed, irrational humans such that it persists
link |
throughout time, and not just maintain the biological body,
link |
but get people from not murdering each other,
link |
like like each other sufficiently to where you kinda
link |
fit well, but I think if songs or poetry or books
link |
taught me anything, if you like each other a little too much,
link |
I mean, the problems arise, because then there's always
link |
a third person who also likes, and then there's the drama,
link |
it's like, I can't believe you did that last night,
link |
whatever, so, and then there's beer.
link |
Gets complicated quickly. Gets complicated quickly.
link |
Okay, anyway, back to the dumb questions,
link |
because you answered this, there's an interview
link |
where you answer a bunch of cool little questions
link |
from young students and so on, about like space.
link |
One of them was playing music in space.
link |
And you mentioned something about what kind of instruments
link |
you could use to play music in space.
link |
Could you mention about like the Spotify work in space,
link |
and if I wanted to do a live performance,
link |
what kind of instruments would I need?
link |
Yeah, I mean, you referenced culture before,
link |
and I think this is one of the most exciting things
link |
that we have at our fingertips, which is to define
link |
a new culture for space exploration.
link |
We don't just have to import cultural artifacts from Earth
link |
to make life worth living in space,
link |
and this musical instrument that you referenced
link |
was a design of an object that could only be performed
link |
So it doesn't sound the same way when it's,
link |
it's a percussive instrument when it's rattled
link |
or moved in a gravity environment, it is unique.
link |
Can we look it up?
link |
It's called the Telematron.
link |
Yeah, it's created by.
link |
Of course it's called the Telematron.
link |
That is so awesome.
link |
Created by Sands Fish and Nicole Boulier,
link |
two amazing graduate students and staff researchers
link |
What does it look like?
link |
It looks steampunk, actually.
link |
Yeah, it's a pretty cool design.
link |
It looks like it's a geometric solid
link |
that has these interesting artifacts on the inside,
link |
and it has a lot of sensors, actually,
link |
additionally on the inside,
link |
like IMU's inertial measurement sensors
link |
that allow it to detect when it's floating
link |
and when it's not floating,
link |
and provides this really kind of ethereal,
link |
they later sonify it.
link |
So they use electronic music to turn it into a symphony
link |
or turn it into a piece.
link |
And yeah, this is the object, the Telematron.
link |
How does the human interact with it?
link |
So it's an interactive musical instrument.
link |
It actually requires another partner.
link |
So the idea was that it's something like a dance
link |
or just like something like a choreography in space.
link |
Speaking of which, you also talked about sports,
link |
and like ball sports, like playing soccer.
link |
So you mentioned that,
link |
so your muscles can move at full speed,
link |
and then if you push off the wall lightly,
link |
you fly across, zoom across.
link |
So how does the physics of that work?
link |
Can you still play soccer, for example, in space?
link |
You can, but one of the most intuitive things
link |
that we all learn as babies, right,
link |
is whenever you throw something,
link |
if I was gonna toss something to you,
link |
because I know that it has to compensate
link |
for the fact that that Keplerian arc is gonna draw it down,
link |
the equations of motion are gonna draw it down.
link |
I would, in space,
link |
I would just shoot something directly towards you,
link |
so like straight in line of sight.
link |
And so that would be very different
link |
for any type of ball sport,
link |
is to retrain your human mind
link |
to have that as your intuitive arc of motion
link |
From your experience,
link |
from understanding how astronauts
link |
get adjusted to this stuff,
link |
how long does it take to adjust to the physics
link |
of this world, this other world?
link |
So even after one or two parabolic flights,
link |
you can gain a certain facility
link |
with moving in that environment.
link |
I think most astronauts would say
link |
maybe several days on station
link |
or a week on station,
link |
and their brain flips.
link |
It's amazing the plasticity of the human brain
link |
and how quickly they are able to adapt.
link |
And so pretty quickly,
link |
they become creatures of this new environment.
link |
Okay, so that's cool.
link |
It's creating a little bit of an experience.
link |
What about if you go for more than 100 days
link |
for one year, for two years, for three years?
link |
What challenges start to emerge in that case?
link |
So Scott Kelly wrote this amazing book
link |
after he spent a year in space,
link |
It's absolutely fantastic
link |
that NASA got to do a twin study.
link |
So he wrote a lot about his experience
link |
on the health side of what changed,
link |
things like bone density, muscle atrophy,
link |
because the shape of your eyeball changes,
link |
which changes your lens,
link |
which changes how you see.
link |
If we're then thinking about the challenges
link |
between a year and three years,
link |
especially if we're doing that three year trip to Mars
link |
for your friend who asked earlier,
link |
then you have to think about nutrition.
link |
And so how are you keeping
link |
all of these different needs for your body alive?
link |
How are you protecting astronauts against radiation?
link |
Either having some type of a shell on the spacecraft,
link |
which is expensive because it's heavy.
link |
If it's something like lead,
link |
a really effective radiation shell,
link |
it's gonna be a lot of mass.
link |
Or is there a pill that could be taken
link |
to try to make you less in danger
link |
of some of the radiation effects?
link |
A lot of this has not yet been answered,
link |
but radiation is a really significant challenge
link |
for that three year journey.
link |
And what are the negative effects of radiation
link |
on the human body out in space?
link |
A higher likelihood to develop cancer at a younger age.
link |
So you'd probably be able to get there and get back,
link |
but you'd find yourself in the same way
link |
of if you were exposed to significant radiation on Earth,
link |
you'd find significant bad health effects as you age.
link |
What do you think about like decades?
link |
Do you think about decades?
link |
Or is this like an entire?
link |
I think about centuries for MySpace.
link |
But yeah, for decades,
link |
I think as soon as we get past the three year mark,
link |
we'll absolutely want,
link |
somewhere between three years and a decade,
link |
we'll want artificial gravity.
link |
And we know how to do that, actually.
link |
The engineering questions still need to be tweaked
link |
for how we'd really implement it,
link |
but the science is there to know
link |
how we would spin habitats in orbit and generate that force.
link |
So even if the entire habitat's not spinning,
link |
you at least have a treadmill part of the space station
link |
and you can spend some fraction of your day
link |
in a near to 1G environment and keep your body healthy.
link |
Wait, literally from just spinning?
link |
From spinning, yes, centripetal force.
link |
That's fascinating. So you generate this force.
link |
If you've ever been in those carnival rides,
link |
the gravitrons that spin you up around the side,
link |
that's the concept.
link |
And this is actually one of the reasons
link |
why we are spinning out a new company
link |
from my MIT lab. Spinning out, ha.
link |
That was accidental, but well noted space pun.
link |
It's like impossible to avoid. Dad jokes, all right.
link |
But yeah, we're spinning out a new company
link |
to look at next generation space architecture,
link |
and how do we actually scale humanity's access to space?
link |
And one of the areas that we wanna look at
link |
is artificial gravity.
link |
Is there a name yet?
link |
Yep, there's a name. We are brand new.
link |
We are just exiting stealth mode.
link |
So your podcast listeners will literally be among
link |
some of the first to hear about it.
link |
It's called Aurelia Institute.
link |
Aurelia is an old English word for chrysalis.
link |
And the idea with this is that we, humanity collectively,
link |
are at this next stage of our metamorphosis,
link |
like a chrysalis, into a spacefaring species.
link |
And so we felt that this was a good time,
link |
a necessary time, to think about
link |
next generation space architecture,
link |
but also Starfleet Academy,
link |
if you know that reference from Star Trek.
link |
Yes, so let me ask a silly sounding, ridiculous sounding,
link |
but probably extremely important question.
link |
Sex and space, including intercourse, conception,
link |
procreation, birth, like being a parent,
link |
like raising the baby.
link |
So basically from birth, well, from the before birth part,
link |
like the birds and the bees and stuff,
link |
and then the whole thing.
link |
How complicated is that?
link |
I remember looking at the, thank you.
link |
I remember looking at this exact Wikipedia page actually,
link |
and I remember being, the Wikipedia page is sex and space,
link |
and fascinating how difficult of an engineering problem
link |
the whole thing is.
link |
Is that something you think about too,
link |
how to have generations of humans?
link |
Self, self replicating organizations.
link |
Yeah, societies essentially.
link |
I mean, I guess with micro,
link |
like if you solve the gravity problem,
link |
you solve a lot of these problems.
link |
That's the hope, yeah.
link |
It's like the central challenge of microgravity
link |
to human reproduction.
link |
But we do host a workshop every year at Beyond the Cradle,
link |
which is the space event that we run at MIT.
link |
And we always do one on pregnancy in space,
link |
or motherhood, or raising children in space,
link |
because there are huge questions.
link |
There've been a few mammal studies
link |
that have looked at reproduction in space,
link |
but there are still really major questions
link |
about how does it work?
link |
How does the fetus evolve in microgravity
link |
if you were pregnant in space?
link |
And I think the near term answer is just gonna be,
link |
we need to be able to give humans a 1G environment
link |
for that phase of our development.
link |
Yeah, so there's some studies on mice in microgravity.
link |
And it's interesting, I think the mice,
link |
like one of them, the mice weren't able to walk,
link |
or their understanding of physics, I guess,
link |
is off or something like that.
link |
Yeah, the mental model when you're really young
link |
and you're kind of getting your mental model of physics,
link |
we do think that that would change kids abilities
link |
to if they were born in microgravity,
link |
their ability to have that intuition
link |
around an Earth based 1G environment might be missing,
link |
because a lot of that is really crystallized
link |
in early development, early childhood development.
link |
So that makes sense that they would see that in mice, yeah.
link |
So what about life when we choose to park our vehicles
link |
on another planet, on the moon, but let's go to Mars?
link |
First of all, is that excite you, humans going to Mars,
link |
like stepping foot on Mars?
link |
And when do you think it'll happen?
link |
It does excite me.
link |
I think visionaries like Elon are working
link |
to make that happen in terms of building the road to space.
link |
We are really excited about building out
link |
the human lived experience of space once you get there.
link |
So how are you going to grow your food?
link |
What is your habitat going to look like?
link |
I think it's profoundly exciting,
link |
but I do think that there's a little bit
link |
of a misunderstanding of Mars anywhere in the near future
link |
being anything like a replacement for Earth.
link |
So it is good for humanity to have these other pockets
link |
of our civilization that can expand out beyond Earth,
link |
but Mars is not in its current state,
link |
a good home for humanity.
link |
Too many perchlorates in the soil,
link |
you can't use that soil to grow crops.
link |
Atmosphere is too thin, certainly can't breathe it,
link |
but it's also just really thin compared to our atmosphere.
link |
A lot of different challenges that would have
link |
to be fundamentally changed on that planet
link |
to make it a good home for a large human civilization.
link |
How does a large civilization of humans get built on Mars?
link |
And where do you think it starts being difficult?
link |
So can you have a small base of like 10 people,
link |
essentially, kind of like the International Space Station
link |
kind of situation, and then can you get it to 100,
link |
to 1,000, to a million?
link |
Are there some interesting challenges there
link |
that worry you, saying that Mars is just not a good backup
link |
at this time for Earth?
link |
I think small outposts, absolutely, like McMurdo, right?
link |
So we have these models of really extreme environments
link |
on Earth in Antarctica, for example,
link |
where humans have been able to go
link |
and make a sustainable settlement.
link |
McMurdo style life on Mars, probably feasible in the 2030s.
link |
So we want to send the first human missions to Mars
link |
and maybe as early as the end of this decade,
link |
more likely early 2030s.
link |
Moving anywhere beyond that in terms of a place
link |
where like an entire human life would be lived,
link |
where it's not just you go for a three month deployment
link |
and you come back, that is actually the big challenge line,
link |
is just saying, is there enough technological sophistication
link |
that can be brought that far out into space?
link |
If you imagine your electronics break,
link |
there's no RadioShack, this dates me a little bit
link |
that my mind jumps to RadioShack,
link |
but there's no supply chains on Mars
link |
that can supply the level of technological sophistication
link |
for all the products that we rely on, on day to day life.
link |
So you'd be going back to actually a very simple existence,
link |
more like pioneer life out West,
link |
in the story of the US, for example.
link |
And I think that the future of larger scale gatherings
link |
of humans in orbit, or sorry, in space,
link |
is actually gonna be in microgravity,
link |
floating space cities, not so much trying
link |
to establish settlements on the surface.
link |
So you think sort of a significant engineering investment
link |
in terms of our efforts and money
link |
should be on large spaceships,
link |
that perhaps are doing this kind of self assembly,
link |
all these kinds of things, and doing it in orbit,
link |
maybe building a giant donut around the planet over time.
link |
Yeah, that is the goal.
link |
And I think the current political climate
link |
is such that you can't get the trillion dollar investment
link |
to start from scratch and build the sci fi megastructure.
link |
But if you can build it in fits and starts,
link |
in little different pieces,
link |
which is another advantage of self assembly,
link |
it's much more like how nature works.
link |
So it's biomimicry inspired way for humanity
link |
to scale out in space.
link |
And whether it's out in space or on Mars,
link |
the idea that sort of two people fall in love,
link |
they have sex, a child is born,
link |
and then that couple has to teach that child
link |
that they came from Earth.
link |
I just love the idea that somebody is born on Mars
link |
or out in space, and you have to be like,
link |
this is not actually like the original home.
link |
Just them looking at Earth and being like,
link |
this is where we came from.
link |
I don't know, that's really inspiring to me.
link |
And the child being really confused
link |
and then wanting to go back to TikTok,
link |
or whatever they do.
link |
Whatever they do in that area.
link |
I mean, there's great sci fi, right,
link |
about people being born on Mars.
link |
And because it's a lower gravity environment,
link |
they're taller, they're more gangly,
link |
if they were actually able to develop there.
link |
And then they come back to Earth
link |
and they're like second class citizens
link |
because they can't function here in the same way
link |
because the gravity's too strong for them.
link |
You see this in series like The Expanse
link |
with the Belters and these different societies
link |
that if we were to succeed in having human societies
link |
grow up in different pockets,
link |
it's not necessarily going to be easy for them
link |
to always come back to Earth as their home.
link |
Yeah, different cultures form,
link |
which is the positive way of phrasing it.
link |
But it's also, this human history teaches us
link |
that we like to form the other.
link |
So there's this kind of conflict
link |
that naturally emerges.
link |
Let me ask another sort of dark question.
link |
What do you think about coming from a military family?
link |
There's still sadly wars in the world.
link |
Do you think wars, military conflicts
link |
will follow us into space, wars between nations?
link |
Like from my perspective currently,
link |
it just seems like space is a place
link |
for scientists and engineers to explore ideas.
link |
But the more and more progress you make,
link |
does it worry you that nations start to step in
link |
and form, that go out and fall out military conflict,
link |
whether it's in cyberspace, in space,
link |
or actual hot war?
link |
I am really concerned about that.
link |
And I do think for decades,
link |
the scientific community in space
link |
has hung on to this notion
link |
from the 1967 Outer Space Treaty,
link |
which is space is the province of all humankind,
link |
peaceful uses of outer space only.
link |
But I do think the rise in tensions
link |
and the geopolitical scene that we're seeing,
link |
I do harbor a lot of concern about hot wars
link |
following humanity out into space.
link |
And it's worth trying to tie nations together
link |
with more collaboration to avoid that happening.
link |
The International Space Station is a great example.
link |
I think it's something like 18 countries
link |
are party to this treaty.
link |
It might be less, it might be more.
link |
And then of course, there's a smaller number of countries
link |
that actually send astronauts.
link |
But even at the fall of the Soviet Union
link |
and through some tense times with Russia,
link |
the ISS had been a place where the US and Russia
link |
were actually able to collaborate between Mir and ISS.
link |
I think it'd be really important right now in particular
link |
to find other platforms where these hegemonic powers
link |
in the world and developing world nations
link |
can come and collaborate on the future of space
link |
and purposefully intertwine our success
link |
so that there's a danger to multiple parties
link |
if somebody is a bad actor.
link |
So we're now talking as there's a war in Ukraine
link |
and I haven't been sleeping much.
link |
I have family, friends, colleagues in both countries.
link |
And I'm just talking to a lot of people,
link |
many of whom are crying, refugees.
link |
And there's a basic human compassion
link |
and love for each other that I believe technology
link |
can help catalyze and accelerate.
link |
But there's also science.
link |
There's something about rockets.
link |
There's something about, and I mean like space exploration
link |
that inspires the world about the positive possibilities
link |
of the human species.
link |
So in terms of Ukraine and Russia and China and India
link |
and the United States and Europe and everywhere else,
link |
it seems like collaborating on giant space projects
link |
is one way to escape these wars,
link |
to escape these sort of geopolitical conflicts.
link |
I mean, there's something,
link |
there's so much camaraderie to the whole thing.
link |
And even in this little period of human history
link |
we're living through, it seems like that's essential.
link |
Even through this pandemic,
link |
there's something so inspiring about those
link |
like SpaceX rockets going up, for example.
link |
This reinvigoration of the space exploration efforts
link |
by the commercial sector, I don't know.
link |
That was, as many of us have,
link |
sort of some dark times during this pandemic,
link |
just like loneliness and sometimes emotion and anger
link |
and just hopelessness and politics.
link |
And then you look at those rockets going up
link |
and it just gives you hope.
link |
So I think that's an understated sort of value
link |
of space exploration,
link |
is the thing that unites us and gives us hope.
link |
Obviously also inspires young generations
link |
and young minds to also contribute
link |
in not necessarily in space exploration
link |
but in all of science and literature and poetry.
link |
There's something about when you look up to the stars
link |
that makes you dream.
link |
And so that's a really good reason
link |
to sort of invest in this,
link |
whether it's building giant megastructure,
link |
which is so freaking cool,
link |
but also colonizing Mars.
link |
Yeah, it's something to look forward to.
link |
Something that, and not make it a domain of war,
link |
but a domain of human collaboration
link |
and human compassion, I think.
link |
You're the founder and director
link |
of the MIT Space Exploration Initiative.
link |
It includes a ton of projects.
link |
So I just wanted to, they're focused, I guess, on life in space
link |
from astrobiology, like we talked about, to habitats.
link |
Are there some other interesting projects,
link |
part of this initiative that pop to mind
link |
that you find particularly cool?
link |
One is the future of in space manufacturing.
link |
So if we're gonna build large scale space structures,
link |
yes, it's great to ship them up from Earth
link |
and self assemble them.
link |
But what about extrusion in orbit?
link |
It's one of the best technologies
link |
to leverage in microgravity
link |
because you can extrude a particularly long beam
link |
that would sag in a normal gravity environment,
link |
but might be able to become the basis of a truss
link |
or a large scale space structure.
link |
So we're doing miniature tests of extrusion
link |
and are excited to fly this
link |
on the International Space Station in a few months.
link |
We are working on swarm robots.
link |
We have just announced actually MIT's return to the moon.
link |
So my organization is leading this mission for MIT,
link |
going back to the surface of the moon
link |
as early as the end of this year, 2022,
link |
and trying to take data from our research payloads
link |
at this historic South Pole site
link |
where NASA is supposed to send the first humans back
link |
on the Artemis III mission.
link |
So our hope is to directly support that human mission
link |
How does that connect to the swarm aspects?
link |
Yeah, so we're actually gonna fly
link |
one of the little astro ants.
link |
That's the current plan.
link |
One of the little swarm robots on the top of a rover.
link |
That's part of the mission.
link |
Ants riding a rover?
link |
Yes, exactly, an ant riding a rover.
link |
That rover gets packed in a lander.
link |
That lander gets packed in a SpaceX rocket.
link |
So it's a whole nesting dolls situation
link |
to get to the moon.
link |
Mother of robot dragons.
link |
So this one, a swarm of one?
link |
Swarm of one, exactly.
link |
We're testing out.
link |
It's a tech demonstration mission,
link |
Yeah, there they are.
link |
Those are the astro ants.
link |
Wow, and this was a distributed system,
link |
and in theory, you could have a ton of these.
link |
Yes, these could also be centralized.
link |
So they have wireless technology
link |
that could also talk to a central base station
link |
and will be assessing kind of case by case
link |
whether it makes sense to operate them
link |
in a decentralized swarm
link |
or to command them in a centralized swarm.
link |
Each robot is equipped with four magnetic wheels
link |
which enable the robot to attach to any magnetic surface
link |
so you can operate basically in any environment.
link |
He tested the, we tested the mobility of all robots
link |
on different materials in a microgravity environment.
link |
On the vomit comet prior to going to the moon.
link |
That must look so cool.
link |
So they're basically moving along different
link |
like metallic surfaces.
link |
It's interesting when you, just a minute ago
link |
talking about the reflection of
link |
how space can be so aspirational and so uniting.
link |
There's a great quote from Bill Anders
link |
from the Apollo 8 mission to the moon,
link |
which is he, it's the Earthrise photo that was taken
link |
where you see the Earth coming up
link |
over the horizon of the moon.
link |
And the quote is something along the lines of
link |
we came all the way to discover the moon
link |
and what we really discovered was the Earth.
link |
This really powerful image looking back.
link |
And so we're also trying to think for our lunar mission
link |
we realized we're a very privileged group at MIT
link |
to get the opportunity to do this.
link |
How could we bring humanity along with us?
link |
And so one of the things we're still testing out
link |
I don't know if we're gonna be able to swing it
link |
would be to do something like a Twitch plays Pokemon
link |
but with the robot.
link |
So let a lot of people on earth actually control the robot
link |
or at least benefit from the data that we're gathering
link |
and try to release the data openly.
link |
So we're exploring a couple of different ideas
link |
for how do we engage more people in this mission.
link |
That would be surreal to be able to interact
link |
in some way with the thing that's out there.
link |
On another surface.
link |
Direct connection.
link |
Direct connection.
link |
I think about artificial intelligence in that same way
link |
which is like building robots
link |
puts a mirror to us humans.
link |
It makes us like wonder about like
link |
what is intelligence?
link |
What is consciousness?
link |
And what is actually valuable about human beings?
link |
When AI system learns to play chess better than humans
link |
you start to let go of this idea
link |
that humans are special because of intelligence.
link |
It's something else.
link |
It's maybe the flame of human consciousness.
link |
It's the capacity to feel deeply
link |
to sort of to both suffer and to love all those things.
link |
And that somehow AI to me sort of puts a mirror to that.
link |
You mentioned HAL 9000.
link |
You have to bring it up with these swarm bots
link |
crawling on the surface of your cocoon in space.
link |
I mean, all right.
link |
Let me steel man the HAL 9000 perspective here.
link |
The poor guy just wanted to maintain the mission
link |
and the astronauts were,
link |
I mean, I don't know if people often talk about that
link |
but like doctors have to make difficult decisions too.
link |
When there's limited resources
link |
you actually do have to sacrifice human life often
link |
because you have to make decisions.
link |
And I think HAL is probably making that kind of decision
link |
about what's more important,
link |
the lives of individual astronauts or the mission.
link |
And I feel like AI and other humans
link |
will need to make these decisions.
link |
And it also feels like AI systems will need to help
link |
make those decisions.
link |
I guess my question is about
link |
greater and greater collective intelligence by systems.
link |
Do you worry about that?
link |
What is the right way to sort of solve this problem
link |
keeping a human in the loop?
link |
Do you think about this kind of stuff
link |
or are they sufficiently dumb now the robots
link |
that that's not yet on the horizon to think about?
link |
I think it should be on the horizon.
link |
It's always good to think about these things early
link |
because we make a lot of technical design decisions
link |
at this phase working with swarm robots
link |
that it would be better to have thought
link |
about some of these questions early
link |
in the life cycle of a project.
link |
There is a real interest in NASA right now
link |
thinking about the future of human robot interaction, HRI,
link |
and what is the right synergy
link |
in terms of level of control for the human
link |
versus level of dependence or control for the robot.
link |
And we're beginning to test out more of these scenarios.
link |
For example, the Gateway Space Station,
link |
which is meant to be in orbit around the moon
link |
as a staging base for the surface operations,
link |
is meant to be able to function autonomously
link |
with no humans in it for months at a time
link |
because they think it's gonna be seasonal.
link |
They think we might not be constantly staffing it.
link |
So this will be a really great test of,
link |
I don't know that anybody's yet worried
link |
about HAL 9000 evolving,
link |
but certainly just the robustness of some of these AI systems
link |
that might be asked to autonomously maintain the station
link |
while the humans are away or detection algorithms
link |
that are gonna say, if you had a human pilot,
link |
they might see debris in orbit and steer around it.
link |
There'll be a lot of autonomous navigation
link |
that has to happen.
link |
That'll be one of the early test beds
link |
where we'll start to get a little bit closer to that future.
link |
Well, the HRI component is really interesting to me,
link |
especially when the I includes like almost friendship
link |
because people don't realize this, I think,
link |
that we humans long for connection.
link |
And when you have even a basic interaction
link |
that's just like supposed to be just like serving you
link |
or something, you still project,
link |
it's still a source of meaning and connection.
link |
And so you do have to think about that.
link |
I mean, HAL 9000, the movie maybe doesn't portray it
link |
that way, but I'm sure there's a relationship there
link |
between the astronauts and the robot,
link |
especially when you have greater and greater level
link |
And maybe that addresses the happiness question too.
link |
Yeah, I think there's a great book by Kate Darling,
link |
who's one of my colleagues at MIT.
link |
Yeah, she's amazing.
link |
She's already been on this podcast,
link |
but we talk all the time and we're supposed to talk
link |
and we've been missing each other
link |
and we're gonna make it happen soon.
link |
Come down to Texas, Kate.
link |
All right, anyway, yeah, she's amazing.
link |
She has this book, her whole work is about this.
link |
Connection with robots, yeah.
link |
This beautiful connection that we have with robots,
link |
but I think it's greater and greater importance
link |
when it's out in space,
link |
because it could help alleviate some of the loneliness.
link |
One of the projects in the book that I gave you,
link |
which is this catalog of the projects
link |
that we've worked on over the last five years,
link |
is this social robot that was developed at the Media Lab.
link |
And we, one of the first years in 2017
link |
that we flew a zero G flight,
link |
we took the social robot along
link |
and tried to do a little bit
link |
of a very scaled down human study
link |
to look at these questions,
link |
because you do imagine that we would form a bond,
link |
a real bond with the social robots
link |
that might be not just serving us on a mission,
link |
but really be our teammates on a future mission.
link |
And I do think that that could have a powerful role
link |
in the mental health and just the stability of a crew
link |
is to have some other robot friends come along.
link |
What do you, by the way, the book you mentioned
link |
is into the Anthropocosmos,
link |
a whole space catalog from the space catalog.
link |
Get that reference.
link |
Yeah, so call out to Earth catalog,
link |
a whole space catalog
link |
from the MIT Space Exploration Initiative.
link |
What about the happiness?
link |
You said that that's one of the problems
link |
of when you're out in space.
link |
How do you keep humans happy?
link |
Again, asking for a friend.
link |
Yes, I mean, one of the big challenges
link |
is you can't just open a window
link |
or walk out a door and blow off steam, right?
link |
You can't just go somewhere to clear your head.
link |
And in that sense, you need to build habitats
link |
that are homes that really care for the humans inside them
link |
and have, whether it's biophilia
link |
and a place where you can go and feel like you're in nature
link |
or a VR headset, which for some people is a poor simulacrum
link |
but is maybe better than nothing.
link |
You need to be thinking
link |
about these technological interventions
link |
that are gonna have to be part of your home
link |
and be part of your maybe day to day ritual
link |
to keep you steady and balanced and happy
link |
or feeling fulfilled.
link |
What about other humans, relationship with other humans?
link |
Do those get weird
link |
when you get past a certain number of humans?
link |
I'm not an expert in this area
link |
but an anecdote that I'll share.
link |
My understanding is that NASA has still not decided
link |
whether it's better to send married couples
link |
or single crew members in terms of,
link |
you want some level of stability,
link |
you don't wanna have the drama of romantic relationships
link |
like you're alluding to before,
link |
but they can't decide because married couples also fight
link |
and have a really tough dynamic.
link |
And so there's a lot of open questions still to answer
link |
about what is the ideal psychological makeup of a crew?
link |
And we're starting to test some of these things
link |
with the civilian crews that are growing up
link |
with Inspiration4, like last fall with SpaceX
link |
and Axe One that's gonna fly in a few days here in March.
link |
As we begin to lengthen the time of those civilian crews,
link |
I think we'll start to learn a little bit more
link |
about just average everyday human to human dynamics
link |
and not the astronauts that are themselves selected
link |
to be perfect human specimens, very good to work with,
link |
easy to get along with.
link |
I wish you collected more data about this pandemic
link |
because I feel like it's a good rough simulation
link |
of what it'd be like out in space.
link |
A lot of people are locked down, some married couples,
link |
I think a lot of marriages broke up,
link |
a lot of marriages got closer together.
link |
So it's like, and then the single people,
link |
some of them went off the cliff
link |
and some of them discovered their new happiness
link |
and meaning and so on.
link |
It's a beautiful little experiment, a painful one.
link |
Is there a thorough way to really test that?
link |
Because it's such a costly experiment
link |
to send humans up there,
link |
but I guess you can always return back to Earth
link |
if it's not working out.
link |
That's what we hope, that's what you hope.
link |
You don't have like a Apollo 13 situation
link |
that doesn't quite make it back.
link |
But yeah, this is also why Mars is such a challenge.
link |
The moon is only three days away.
link |
That's a lot quicker to recover from
link |
if there's a psychological problem with the crew
link |
or any type of maintenance problem, anything.
link |
Three years is such a challenge
link |
compared to these other domains
link |
that we've been getting more used to
link |
in terms of human spaceflight.
link |
So this is a question that we will need to have explored more
link |
before we start really sending crews to Mars.
link |
So you're a young scientist, do you think in your lifetime
link |
you will go out into orbit,
link |
you will go out beyond into deep space
link |
and potentially step, you,
link |
I don't know if you can call yourself a civilian.
link |
I don't know if that's what you count as,
link |
but you as a curious ant from MIT land step on Mars.
link |
That's a firm, that's a firm.
link |
Are you coming back?
link |
Firm, yes, yeah, I'm coming back.
link |
I don't want that one way mission, I want the two way mission.
link |
But yes, I mean, I think we're already talking
link |
about a pretty near term opportunity
link |
where I could send graduate students
link |
to the International Space Station.
link |
Yeah, not a sacrifice, but send graduate students.
link |
For the experience.
link |
For the experience.
link |
Send graduate students to the ISS to do their research.
link |
I do think you and I both would have an opportunity
link |
to go to a lunar base of some sort within our lifetime.
link |
And there's a good chance if we really wanted to,
link |
we might have to really advocate for it,
link |
apply to an astronaut program.
link |
There will be some avenues for humans
link |
in our lifetime to go to Mars.
link |
What's the bar for like health?
link |
Do you think that bar will keep getting lower and lower
link |
in terms of how healthy, how athletic,
link |
like how the psychological profile,
link |
all those kinds of things?
link |
Yeah, for one, we're gonna build more robust habitats
link |
that don't depend on astronauts
link |
being so impeccably well trained.
link |
So we're gonna make it better for inclusion
link |
and just opening access to space.
link |
But there's a fantastic group called Astro Access
link |
that is already helping disabled space flyers
link |
do zero G flights and potentially get access to the ISS.
link |
And some of the things that we think of
link |
as disabilities on earth are hyper abilities in space.
link |
You don't need really powerful legs in space.
link |
What you'd really benefit from having is a third arm,
link |
more ways to kind of move yourself around
link |
and grip and interact.
link |
So we are already seeing a much more open minded approach
link |
to who gets to go to space and Astro Access
link |
is a wonderful organization doing some of that work.
link |
I'm hoping introversion will also be a superpower in space.
link |
Okay, well, first I'd love to get your opinion
link |
on commercial space flight, what SpaceX,
link |
what Blue Origin are doing.
link |
And also another question on top of that is,
link |
because you've worked with a lot of different kinds
link |
of people, culturally, what's the difference
link |
between SpaceX or commercial type of efforts
link |
Yeah, so the first part of your question,
link |
I am thrilled by all of the commercial activity in space.
link |
It has really empowered our program.
link |
So instead of me waiting for five years to get a grant
link |
and get the money from the grant
link |
and only then can you send a project to space,
link |
I go out and I fundraise a lot like a startup founder
link |
and I directly buy access to space
link |
on the International Space Station
link |
through SpaceX or NanoRacks, same with Blue Origin
link |
and their suborbital craft, same with Axiom now.
link |
Axiom's making plans for their own commercial space station.
link |
It's not out of the realm of possibility,
link |
but in a few years, I will rent lab space in orbit.
link |
I will rent a module from the Axiom space station
link |
or the orbital reef, which is the Blue Origin space station
link |
or NanoRacks is thinking about Starlab Oasis.
link |
There's probably some other companies
link |
that I'm not even aware of yet
link |
that are doing commercial space habitats.
link |
So I think that's fabulous
link |
and really empowering for our research.
link |
So like loosely speaking, does it become affordable
link |
for like MIT type of research lab?
link |
Does it, or does it need to be a multi university
link |
like a gigantic effort, a consortium thing?
link |
One of the reasons we're spinning out Aurelia
link |
is we actually realized it's cheap enough.
link |
It doesn't even have to be MIT.
link |
And we wanted to start democratizing access
link |
to these spaceflight opportunities
link |
to a much broader swath of humanity.
link |
Could you take a Khan Academy educational course
link |
about, hey, students around the world,
link |
this is how you get ready for a zero G flight.
link |
And by the way, come fly with us next year,
link |
which is something we're gonna do with Aurelius.
link |
We're gonna bring much more just kind of day to day folks
link |
on zero G flights and get them access
link |
to engaging in the space industry.
link |
So it's become cheap enough
link |
and the prices have dropped enough to consider even that.
link |
So that's amazing.
link |
It definitely doesn't have to be a consortium
link |
of universities anymore.
link |
Depends on what you wanna fly.
link |
If you wanna fly James Webb,
link |
a huge telescope that's decades in the making,
link |
sure, you need a NASA allocation budget.
link |
You need billions.
link |
But for a lot of the stuff in the book
link |
and our research portfolio,
link |
it's actually becoming far more accessible.
link |
So that's a commercial.
link |
What about NASA and MIT academia?
link |
Yeah, I think people have been worried about NASA
link |
the last few years because in some people's minds,
link |
they are ceding ground to these commercial efforts,
link |
but that's really not what's happening.
link |
NASA empowered these commercial efforts
link |
because they wanna free themselves up to go to Mars
link |
and go to Europa and continue being
link |
that really aspirational force for humanity
link |
of pushing the boundary, always pushing the boundary.
link |
And if they were anchored in low earth orbit,
link |
maintaining a space station indefinitely,
link |
that's so much a part of their budget
link |
that it was keeping them from being able to do more.
link |
So it actually is really fantastic for NASA
link |
to have grown this commercial ecosystem
link |
and then that frees NASA up to go further.
link |
And in academia, we like to think that we will be able
link |
to do the provocative next generation research
link |
that is going to unlock things at that frontier.
link |
And we can partner with NASA.
link |
We can go through a program
link |
if we wanna send a probe out really far,
link |
but we can also partner with SpaceX
link |
and see what human life in a SpaceX Mars settlement
link |
might look like and how we could design for that.
link |
Speaking of projects, maybe are there other projects
link |
that pop to mind from the Space Exploration Initiative
link |
or maybe stuff from the book that you can mention?
link |
Something super cool.
link |
I mean, everything we've been talking about is cool,
link |
but just something that pops to mind again.
link |
Yeah, so we talked about life in space
link |
and you might need more arms than legs.
link |
One of the projects by Valentina Sumini
link |
was a air powered robotics tail.
link |
So it's a soft robotics tail
link |
that essentially has a little camera on the back end of it,
link |
can do computer vision and knows where to grapple.
link |
So it's behind you.
link |
It grapples onto something and holds you in space
link |
and then you can actually free up
link |
both of your hands to work.
link |
So we're already starting to think about
link |
the design of bionic humans or prosthetics
link |
or things that would make you kind of like a cyborg
link |
to augment your capabilities
link |
when you're in a space environment.
link |
How would you control something like that?
link |
So it's kind of like a, I mean, you can't call it a leg,
link |
but whatever, it's a. An additional appendage.
link |
Appendage, so how would you,
link |
what are ideas for controlling something like that?
link |
Yeah, so right now it's super, yeah, there you go.
link |
Right now it's super manual.
link |
It's basically just like a kind of a set pattern
link |
of inflating as we're testing it.
link |
But in the future, if we had a Neuralink,
link |
I mean, this is something that you could imagine
link |
directly controlling,
link |
just thinking thoughts and controlling it.
link |
That's a ways away.
link |
Yeah, so we talked about on the biology side,
link |
astrobiology, there's probably agriculture stuff.
link |
Is there other things that kind of feed the ecosystem
link |
of out in space for survival
link |
or the robotics architectures, the self assembly stuff?
link |
So kind of combining something we were talking about,
link |
you can form these relationships with objects
link |
and anthropomorphize.
link |
One of the things that we're thinking about for agriculture
link |
created by Manwe and Somu, so two students at MIT,
link |
was this little, it looks like a planet,
link |
but it's inspired by, I think, a Mandala
link |
or Nepalese spinning wheel.
link |
And you plant plants on the inside
link |
and the astronaut has to spin it every day
link |
to help the plants survive.
link |
So it's a way to give the astronauts
link |
something to care about,
link |
something that they are responsible for keeping alive
link |
and can really invest themselves in.
link |
And it's not necessary, right?
link |
We have other ways to grow in orbit,
link |
hydroponics, liquid medium,
link |
trying to keep the liquid around the plant roots is hard
link |
because there's no gravity to pull it down
link |
in a particular direction.
link |
But what I loved about this project was they said,
link |
sure, we have ways that the plants could grow on their own,
link |
but the astronauts might want to care for it
link |
in the same way that we have little plants
link |
that come to be important to us, little plant friends.
link |
So there's AgriFuge, that's an early model
link |
of this manually spinning plant habitat.
link |
I guess this is the best of academic research
link |
is you can do these kinds of wild ideas.
link |
Well, I get to spend quite a bit of time
link |
with Mr. Elon Musk and he's very stressed,
link |
especially about Starship
link |
and all those kinds of engineering efforts.
link |
What do you think about how damn hard it is
link |
to get out of space?
link |
Like, are we humans gonna be able to do this?
link |
I don't know, I think it feels like
link |
it's an engineering problem, it's a scientific problem,
link |
but it's also just a motivation problem
link |
for the entire human species.
link |
And you also need to have superstar researchers
link |
and engineers working on it.
link |
So you have to get like the best people in the world,
link |
inspire them and starting from a young age and kind of.
link |
Almost inculcating us into why we do it.
link |
I mean, I guess that's why it's exciting.
link |
You don't know if we're gonna be able to pull this off.
link |
Like, we could like fail miserably.
link |
And that, I suppose, I mean,
link |
that's where the best of engineering is done
link |
is like success is not guaranteed.
link |
And even if it happens, it might be very painful.
link |
I think that's what's so special
link |
about what Elon is doing with SpaceX
link |
is he takes these risks and he tests iteratively
link |
and he'll, we'll see the spectacular failures
link |
on the path to a successful Starship.
link |
It's something that, you know, people have said,
link |
why isn't NASA doing that?
link |
Well, that's cause NASA is doing that with taxpayer dollars
link |
and we would all revolt if we saw NASA failing
link |
at all these different stages.
link |
But that level of, you know,
link |
spiral engineering theory of development
link |
isn't super impressive.
link |
And it's a really interesting approach
link |
that SpaceX has taken.
link |
And I think between people like Elon and Jeff Bezos
link |
and Firefly and NASA and ESO, we are gonna get there.
link |
They're building the road to space.
link |
These trailblazers are doing it.
link |
And now part of the challenge is to get the rest
link |
of the public to understand that it's happening, right?
link |
A lot of people don't know that we're going back
link |
to the moon, that we're gonna send the first woman
link |
to the moon within a few years.
link |
A lot of people don't know
link |
that there are commercial space stations in orbit,
link |
that it's not just NASA that does space stuff.
link |
So we have a big challenge to get more of humanity excited
link |
and educated and involved again,
link |
kind of like in the Apollo era
link |
where it was a big deal for everybody.
link |
Well, a lot of that is also one of the big impressive things
link |
that Elon does, I think, extremely well
link |
is the social media, is the getting people excited.
link |
And I think that actually, he's helped NASA
link |
step their game up in terms of social media.
link |
There's something about, yeah, the storytelling,
link |
but also not like, you know, like authentic
link |
and just real and raw engineering.
link |
There's a lot of excitement for that humor and fun also.
link |
All of those things you realize,
link |
the thing that make up the virality of the meme
link |
is beautiful, you have to kind of embrace that.
link |
And to me, this kind of,
link |
I criticize a lot of companies based on this.
link |
I talked to a bunch of CEOs and so on,
link |
and it's just like, there's a caution,
link |
like let us do this like press conference thing
link |
where when the final product is ready
link |
and it's overproduced,
link |
as opposed to the raw, the gritty just showed off.
link |
I mean, something that I think MIT is very good at doing
link |
is just showing the raw, by nature, the mess of it.
link |
And the mess of it is beautiful
link |
and people get really excited and failure is really exciting.
link |
When the thing blows up and you're like, oh shit,
link |
that makes it even more exciting when it doesn't blow up.
link |
And doing all of that on social media
link |
and showing also the humans behind it,
link |
the individual young researchers or the engineers
link |
or the leaders where everything's at stake.
link |
I don't know, I think I'm really excited about that.
link |
I do want MIT to do that more for students
link |
to show off their stuff and not be pressured
link |
to do this kind of generic official presentation,
link |
but show their, become a YouTuber also.
link |
Like show off your raw research
link |
as you're working on it in the early days.
link |
I hope that's the future.
link |
Things like, I was teasing about TikTok earlier,
link |
but these kinds of things I think inspire young people
link |
to show off their stuff, to show their true self,
link |
the rawness of it,
link |
because I think that's where engineering is best.
link |
And I think that will inspire people
link |
about all the cool stuff we could do out in space.
link |
I should say, I couldn't agree more.
link |
And I actually think that this is why we need
link |
a real life Starfleet Academy right now.
link |
It was the place where the space cadets got to go
link |
to learn about how to engage in a future of life in space.
link |
And we can do it in a much better way.
link |
There are a bunch of groups that traditionally
link |
haven't thought that they could engage in aerospace,
link |
whether it's because you were told
link |
you had to be into math and science.
link |
Now we need space lawyers,
link |
we need space artists like Grimes, right?
link |
We need really creative, profoundly interesting people
link |
to wanna see themselves in that future.
link |
And I think it's a big challenge to us
link |
in the space industry to also do some more diversity,
link |
equity and inclusion,
link |
and show a broader swath of society
link |
that there's a future for them
link |
in this space exploration vision.
link |
Let me push back on one thing.
link |
We don't need space lawyers.
link |
Okay, it's a joke.
link |
We do, we do, we do.
link |
The lawyers are great, I love them.
link |
Okay, let me ask a big, ridiculous question.
link |
What is the most beautiful idea to you
link |
about space exploration?
link |
Whether it's the engineering, the astrobiology,
link |
the science, the inspiration, the human happiness,
link |
or aliens, I don't know.
link |
What do you, like, inspires you every day
link |
in terms of its beauty, in terms of its awe?
link |
As a ex physicist, what I've always found so profound
link |
is just that at really, really small scales,
link |
like particle physics,
link |
and really, really big scales, like astrophysics,
link |
there are similarities in the way
link |
that those systems behave and look,
link |
and there's a certain beautiful symmetry in the universe
link |
that's just kind of waiting for us
link |
to tie together the physics and really understand it.
link |
That is something that just really captivates me,
link |
and I would love to,
link |
even though I'm now much more
link |
on the applied space exploration side,
link |
I really try to keep up with what's happening
link |
in those physics areas,
link |
because I think that will be a huge answer for humanity
link |
along the lines of, are we alone in the universe?
link |
One of the fascinating things about you
link |
is you have a degree in physics, mathematics,
link |
and philosophy, and now, I don't know,
link |
would you call it aerospace engineering maybe kind of thing?
link |
So you have at a foot in all of these worlds,
link |
the theoretic, the beauty of that world,
link |
and the philosophy somehow is in there,
link |
and now the very practical, pragmatic implementation
link |
of all these wild ideas,
link |
plus your incredible communicator, all of those things.
link |
What did you pick up from those different disciplines?
link |
Or maybe I'm just romanticizing
link |
all those different disciplines,
link |
but what did you pick up from the variety
link |
of that physics, mathematics, philosophy?
link |
What I loved about having this chance
link |
to do a liberal arts education
link |
was trying to understand the human condition,
link |
and I think more designers for space exploration
link |
should be thinking about that,
link |
because there's so much depth of,
link |
like we were talking about,
link |
issues and opportunities around human connection,
link |
human life, meaning in life.
link |
How do you find fulfillment or happiness?
link |
And I think if you approach these questions
link |
just purely from the standpoint of an engineer
link |
or a scientist, you'll miss some of what
link |
makes it a life worth living.
link |
And so I love being able to combine
link |
some of this notion of philosophy
link |
and the human condition with my work,
link |
but I'm also a pragmatist,
link |
and I didn't want to stay just purely
link |
in these big picture questions about the universe.
link |
I wanted to have an impact on society,
link |
and I also felt like I had such a wonderful childhood
link |
and a really fantastic setup that I owe society some work
link |
to really make a positive impact
link |
for a broader swath of citizens.
link |
And so that kind of led me from the physics domain
link |
to thinking about engineering and practical questions
link |
for life in space.
link |
In physics, was there a dream?
link |
Are you also captivated by this search
link |
for the theory of everything that kind of unlocks
link |
the deeper and deeper, in the simple, elegant way,
link |
the function of our universe?
link |
Do you think that'll be useful for us
link |
for the actual practical engineering things
link |
that you're working on now?
link |
I mean, I worked at CERN for two summers in undergrad,
link |
and we were looking for supersymmetry,
link |
which was one of these alternatives to the standard model.
link |
And it was sad because my professors
link |
were getting sadder and sadder
link |
because they weren't finding it.
link |
They were excluding what we would call this parameter space
link |
of finding these supersymmetric particles.
link |
But the search for what that theory of everything could be,
link |
or a grand unified theory that kind of answers
link |
some of the holes within the standard model of physics
link |
would presumably kind of unlock a better understanding
link |
of certain fundamental physical laws
link |
that we should be able to build a better understanding
link |
of engineering and day to day services from that.
link |
It might not be an immediately obvious thing.
link |
When we discovered the Higgs boson,
link |
I was there at CERN that day.
link |
It was July 4th, 2012 that it was announced.
link |
We all waited like nerds overnight in line
link |
to get into the announcement chamber.
link |
I'd never waited for even like a Harry Potter premiere
link |
in my life, but we waited for this announcement
link |
of the Higgs boson to get into the chamber overnight.
link |
But did that immediately translate
link |
to technology for engineering?
link |
No, but it's still a really important part
link |
of our understanding of these fundamental laws of physics.
link |
And so I don't know that it's always immediate,
link |
but I think it is really critical knowledge
link |
for humanity to seek.
link |
It might just shake up understanding of the world.
link |
What scares me is it might help us create
link |
more dangerous weapons.
link |
So, and then we'll figure out that great filter situation.
link |
And I still believe that human compassion and love
link |
is actually the way to defend against all these greater
link |
and greater and more impressive weapons.
link |
Let me ask a weird question in terms
link |
of you disagreeing with others.
link |
What important idea do you believe is true
link |
that many others don't agree with you on?
link |
Maybe, it's a tough question.
link |
You might have to think about that one,
link |
but whether it's very specific,
link |
like which material to use or something
link |
about a particular project,
link |
or it could be grand priorities on missions.
link |
I think one you actually mentioned is interesting
link |
is like the thing we should be looking for
link |
is like colonization of space
link |
versus colonization of planets.
link |
Yes, it's probably my best hot take
link |
that people would disagree with me on
link |
is life in floating cities
link |
as opposed to life on the surface.
link |
How do you envision that like spread of humans?
link |
Cause you said at the beginning of the conversation,
link |
something about like scale, increasing the scale
link |
of basically humans in space.
link |
Are they just like in, they're in orbit
link |
and then they get a little farther and farther out.
link |
Like, do you see this kind of floating cities
link |
just getting farther and farther from earth?
link |
They can always kind of return,
link |
but like if you look a few centuries from now,
link |
do you just see us, all these like floating cities.
link |
And it just kind of envelops the space around us
link |
in these like neighborhoods.
link |
Yeah, in these neighborhoods.
link |
It's like rural and there's like giant structures
link |
and there's small pirate structures
link |
and that kind of stuff.
link |
Pirate structures, yeah.
link |
I think low earth orbit might come to look like that.
link |
And it's a really interesting regulatory challenge
link |
to make sure that there's some cross purposes.
link |
So the more cool space cities we have in orbit,
link |
the more shiny objects in the night sky,
link |
the worse it is for astronomers
link |
in a really kind of overly simplified case.
link |
So there's some pushback to this like Amoebaing
link |
where we just grow kind of incongruously
link |
or indiscriminately as an Amoeba in low earth orbit.
link |
Beyond that though, I think we'll grow in pockets
link |
where there are resources.
link |
So we won't just expand around the gravity well of earth.
link |
We'll do some development around the moon,
link |
some development around asteroids,
link |
some development around Mars,
link |
because there'll always be purposes
link |
for which we wanna go down to a physical object
link |
and study it or extract something or learn from it.
link |
But I think we'll grow in fits and starts in pockets.
link |
Some of the coolest pockets are the gravity balanced pockets
link |
like the Lagrange points, which is where we just sent,
link |
we not me personally, but NASA just sent James Webb,
link |
the big telescope, I think it's at L2.
link |
What's the nice feature about those pockets?
link |
So it's a stable orbit.
link |
There are several different Lagrange points.
link |
And so it just requires less energy
link |
to stay where you're trying to stay.
link |
Yeah, that's fascinating.
link |
What's also fascinating is the interaction
link |
between nations on that regard.
link |
Like who owns that?
link |
Would you say in those floating cities,
link |
do you envision independent governments?
link |
That was gonna be my next answer to you,
link |
which pushed me harder for a more provocative question
link |
where I might disagree with other people.
link |
I don't yet have my own opinions fully formed on this,
link |
but we are trying to figure out right now
link |
what happens to the moon
link |
with all of these first come first served actors
link |
just arriving and setting precedents
link |
that might really affect future access.
link |
And one example is property rights.
link |
We do want companies that have the expertise
link |
to go to the moon and mine stuff
link |
that will help us develop a human settlement there
link |
or a gateway, but companies need to know generally
link |
that they have rights to a certain area
link |
or that they have some legal right to sell things
link |
that they're getting.
link |
Does that mean we're gonna grant property rights
link |
on the moon to companies who has the right
link |
to give that right away?
link |
So there's a bunch of really kind of gnarly questions
link |
that we have to think about,
link |
which is why I think we need space lawyers.
link |
Maybe that's the true provocative answers.
link |
I think we need space lawyers.
link |
I mean, yeah, yeah, I mean, but those questions,
link |
again, as you said eloquently,
link |
will help us answer questions about here on Earth.
link |
It is a little strange.
link |
I mean, it's obvious, but it's also strange
link |
if you look at the big picture of it all
link |
that we draw these like borders around geographical areas
link |
and we say, this is mine, like,
link |
and then we fight wars over what's mine
link |
and not, it seems like there's possible alternatives,
link |
but also it seems like there needs to be a public ownership
link |
of some parts, like, what is it?
link |
Central Park in New York.
link |
Is there something like preserving?
link |
Yeah, the commons.
link |
That's why we titled the book Into the Anthropocosmos.
link |
We know it's a long and kind of a mouthful,
link |
but this notion of the Anthropocene,
link |
we have a lot of commons problems in humanity.
link |
How are we treating the Earth, global climate change?
link |
How are we gonna treat and behave in space?
link |
How can we be responsible stewards of the space commons?
link |
And I would love to see an approach to the moon
link |
that is commons based, but it's hard to know
link |
who would be the protector or the enforcer of that.
link |
And if it's, which it will be probably in the early days,
link |
a lot of companies sort of working on the moon,
link |
working on Mars, working out in space,
link |
it feels like there still needs to be
link |
a civilian representation of like the greater effort
link |
or something like that.
link |
Like where there should be a president,
link |
there should be a democracy of some kind
link |
where people can vote.
link |
Some representative government.
link |
Those are all, again, the same human questions.
link |
What advice would you give to a young person today
link |
thinking about what they wanna do with their life, career?
link |
So somebody in high school, somebody in college,
link |
maybe somebody that looks up to the stars
link |
and dreams to one day, take a one way ticket to Mars
link |
or to contribute something to the effort.
link |
I'd say you should feel empowered
link |
because it's really the first time in human history
link |
that we're at this cusp of interplanetary civilization.
link |
And I don't think we're gonna lapse back from it.
link |
So the future is incredibly bright for young people
link |
that even younger than you and I,
link |
who will actually really get a chance to go to Mars
link |
The other thing I would say is be open minded
link |
about what your own interests are.
link |
I don't think you anymore have to be shoehorned
link |
into a particular career to be welcomed
link |
into the future of space exploration.
link |
If you are an artist and that is your passion,
link |
but you would love to do space art or if not space art,
link |
use your artistry to communicate a feeling
link |
or a message about space.
link |
That's a role that we desperately need
link |
just as much as we need space scientists
link |
and space engineers, so.
link |
Well, when you look at your own life,
link |
you're an incredibly accomplished scientist,
link |
young scientist, but you know,
link |
and you hopped around from physics to aerospace.
link |
So going from the biggest theoretical ideas
link |
to the biggest practical ideas.
link |
Is there something from your own journey
link |
you can give advice to,
link |
like how to end up doing incredible research at MIT?
link |
Maybe the role of the university and college
link |
and education and learning, all that kind of stuff.
link |
I'd say one piece of advice is find really good teammates
link |
because I get to be the one that's talking to you,
link |
but there are 50 graduate students, staff and faculty
link |
that are part of my organization back at MIT.
link |
And I'm actually, you guys can't see it on camera,
link |
but I'm sitting here with my co founder and COO,
link |
Danielle DeLotte, and that is really what makes
link |
these large scale challenges for humanity possible
link |
is really fantastic teams working together
link |
to scale more than what I could do alone.
link |
So I think that that's an important model
link |
that we don't talk about enough in academia.
link |
There's a big push for this like lone wolf genius figure
link |
in academia, but that's certainly not been the case
link |
I've had wonderful collaborators and people
link |
that I work with along the team.
link |
Also cross disciplinary.
link |
Cross disciplinary, interdisciplinary,
link |
whatever you wanna call it, but.
link |
Artists, where do artists come in?
link |
Do you work with artists?
link |
We have an arts curator
link |
on the space exploration initiative side.
link |
She helps make sure partly around that communication
link |
challenge that we talked about,
link |
that we're not just doing zero G flights
link |
and space missions, but that we take our artifacts
link |
of this sci fi space future to museums
link |
and galleries and exhibits.
link |
She pushed me to make sure her name is Shinglu.
link |
She pushed me for our first ISS mission.
link |
I was just gathering all the engineering payloads
link |
that I wanted to support for the students to fly,
link |
including my own work.
link |
And she said, you know what?
link |
We should do an open call internationally
link |
for artists to send something to the ISS.
link |
And we found out it was the first time.
link |
We were the first ever international open call
link |
for art to go to the ISS.
link |
And that was thanks to Shing, an artist bringing
link |
a perspective that I might not have thought
link |
about prioritizing, so.
link |
Yeah, that's awesome.
link |
So when you look out there,
link |
it's the flame of human consciousness.
link |
There does seem to be something quite special
link |
Well, first of all, what do you think it is?
link |
What's consciousness?
link |
What are we trying to preserve here?
link |
What is it about humans that should be preserved
link |
or life here on earth?
link |
What gives you hope to try to expand it out
link |
farther and farther?
link |
Like, what makes you sad if it was all gone?
link |
I think we're a remarkable species
link |
that we are aware of our own thoughts.
link |
We are meta aware of our own thoughts
link |
And we're able to speak on a podcast
link |
about our meta awareness, about our own thoughts.
link |
About our own thoughts, yeah.
link |
Turtles all the way down.
link |
I think that that is a really special gift
link |
that we have been given as a species
link |
and that there's a worth to expanding
link |
our circles of awareness.
link |
So we're very aware of, as an earth based species,
link |
we've become a little bit more aware
link |
of the fragility of earth and how special a place it is
link |
when we go to the moon and we look back.
link |
What would it mean for us to have a presence
link |
and our purpose in life as a inter solar system species
link |
or eventually an intergalactic species?
link |
I think it's a really profound opportunity
link |
for exploration, for the sake of exploration.
link |
A real gift for the human mind.
link |
Yeah, for anything, we're curious creatures.
link |
You see, you do believe we might one day
link |
become intergalactic civilizations.
link |
Long, long time from now.
link |
We have a lot of propulsion challenges
link |
to answer to get that far.
link |
So you have a hope for this.
link |
Another big ridiculous question building on top of that.
link |
What do you think is the meaning of life?
link |
This individual life of ours, your life,
link |
that unfortunately has to come to an end
link |
as far as we know for now.
link |
And our life here together, is there a why?
link |
Or do we just kinda like let our curiosity carry us away?
link |
Is there a single kind of driving purpose why
link |
or can it just be curiosity based?
link |
I certainly feel, and this is not the scientist
link |
in me talking, but just more of like a human soul talking.
link |
I certainly feel some sense of purpose
link |
and meaning in my life.
link |
And there's a version of that
link |
that's a very local level within my family,
link |
which is funny because this whole conversation
link |
has been big, grand space exploration themes.
link |
But you asked me this question
link |
and my first thought is what really matters to me,
link |
my family, my biological reproducing unit.
link |
But then there's also another purpose,
link |
like another version of the meaning in my life
link |
that is trying to do good things for humanity.
link |
So that sense that we can be individual humans
link |
and have our local meaning,
link |
and we can also be global humans.
link |
Maybe someday like the Star Trek utopia
link |
will all be global citizens.
link |
I don't wanna sound too naive.
link |
But there is I think that beauty to a meaning
link |
and a purpose of your life that's bigger than yourself,
link |
working on something that's bigger and grander
link |
than just yourself.
link |
The deepest meaning is from
link |
the local biological reproduction unit.
link |
And then it goes to the engineering scientific,
link |
what is it, corporate like company unit
link |
that can actually produce and compete
link |
and interact with the world.
link |
And then there's the giant human unit
link |
that's struggling with pandemics.
link |
And together struggling against the forces of nature
link |
that keeps wanting to kill us.
link |
Yeah, there'd be nothing like an alien invasion
link |
to unite the planet, we think.
link |
I can't wait, bring it on aliens.
link |
Listen, your work, you're an incredible communicator,
link |
incredible young scientist there.
link |
It's huge honor that you would spend your time with me.
link |
I can't wait what you do in the future.
link |
And thank you for representing MIT so beautifully,
link |
You're an incredible person.
link |
Thank you for talking to me.
link |
Thank you so much for having me.
link |
It's been an absolute pleasure.
link |
It's a great conversation.
link |
Thanks for listening to this conversation
link |
with Ariel Ekblah.
link |
To support this podcast,
link |
please check out our sponsors in the description.
link |
And now let me leave you with some words from Seneca,
link |
the Roman stoic philosopher.
link |
There is no easy way from earth to the stars.
link |
Thank you for listening and hope to see you next time.